Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Terry Cook's avatar

Thanks for the picture of a Ghost Shark; a creative blend of technology and deep sea intelligence gathering.

Luther's avatar

Thanks for the analysis Mick. As usual, you have walked me back from the edge of despair in how we are handling Defence. Nonetheless, is the strategic framing really all that different? We have been saying for at least 5 years that the 10 year window is collapsing. No matter how many times we say it without acting on it substantially, it just sounds more and more ridiculous.

I also wonder if 'strategic reliance' is starting to also sound like we need to rethink the horse we are riding: I think we were intensely lucky and right to easily slot into the American sphere of influence from the British sphere after WW2. But now I do wonder if we were just lucky in backing the morally right horse then and that now we need to think a little more deeply and prepare for the worst.

The seemingly bright spot of funding feels like a con. I just don't think that the government is being honest or really proactive here. It is increasingly a shell game that the politicians and bureaucrats use to LOOK like they are doing something, without actually doing it. ASPI has some great analysis on this governmental 'scam'.

I am heartened to see a broader definition of Defence though. This is good to see, and as Defence has previously stated, this is now a whole of nation effort. I hope it is not a ploy to just make it look like they are spending more money by lumping in lots of other items. I am not certain that the defence planners are thinking more than one derivative down. I used to be confident they were but now I am unsure.

NOW, Senior Officer Bloat is an issue and part of the culture and intransigence problem. As an aside, I do wonder if there were an analysis of the past correlation (probably not causation) of senior rank bloat to commencement of hostilities, if we would find that we are getting close to that inception point. My instinct says we are not far off.

No posts

Ready for more?